| Last | First | Class of | College | College Sport | Div. | Trinity Sport |
| Bourne | Sydney | 2026 | Barton College | Lacrosse | II | Lacrosse |
| Boykin | Sara Grace | 2026 | Virginia Military Institute | Track & Field | I | Field Hockey, Track & Field, Lacrosse |
| Brotherton | Jack | 2026 | Roanoke College | Football | III | Football, Lacrosse |
| Brown | Davion | 2026 | Virginia Tech | Football | I | Football |
| DeFrancesca | Sam | 2026 | University of Richmond | Football | I | Football, Track & Field |
| Fischi | Frances | 2026 | Randolph-Macon College | Basketball | III | Basketball |
| Fischi | Vinny | 2026 | George Mason University | Baseball | I | Baseball |
| Foster | Kensey | 2026 | Susquehanna University | Basketball, Lacrosse | III | Basketball, Lacrosse |
| German | Jalen | 2026 | Coastal Carolina University | Baseball | I | Baseball |
| Giesen | Owen | 2026 | Hampden-Sydney College | Baseball | III | Baseball |
| Hargan | Sean | 2026 | Morgan State Univeristy | Football | I | Football |
| Johnson | Avery | 2026 | St. Joseph's University | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey, Lacrosse |
| Logan | Lilah Grace | 2026 | Penn State University | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey |
| Love | Mason | 2026 | Howard University | Football | I | Football |
| Love | Miles | 2026 | Howard University | Football | I | Football |
| Mills | Ruby | 2026 | Roanoke College | Lacrosse | III | Lacrosse |
| Montgomery | Kyan | 2026 | Hampden-Sydney College | Football | III | Football, Basketball |
| Parks | Carson | 2026 | Christopher Newport University | Football | III | Football |
| Riesser | Anna | 2026 | Old Dominion University | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey, Lacrosse |
| Rosen | Ben | 2026 | Bridgewater College | Football | III | Football, Lacrosse |
| Stone | Hugh | 2026 | Carnegie Mellon University | Football | III | Football, Basketball, Golf |
| Versen | Lucy | 2026 | University of Richmond | Track & Field | I | Track & Field |
| Whitehead | Susanna | 2026 | Washington and Lee University | Tennis | III | Tennis |
| Last | First | Class of | College | College Sport | Div. | Trinity Sport |
| Beatty | Karsin | 2025 | Syracuse University | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey, Softball |
| Benitez | Tony | 2025 | Hampden-Sydney College | Baseball | III | Baseball |
| Brooks | Braxton | 2025 | Christopher Newport University | Football | III | Football |
| Edwards | Deuce | 2025 | Michigan State University | Football | I | Football, Winter Track, Track |
| Friedman | Dylan | 2025 | Virginia Military Institute | Football | I | Football, Baseball |
| Gallinger | Greg | 2025 | Hampden-Sydney College | Lacrosse | III | Lacrosse |
| Hartley | Cole | 2025 | Milligan University | Baseball | II | Baseball |
| Hobbs | Jackson | 2025 | Averett University | Baseball | III | Baseball |
| Lawler | Ashton | 2025 | Hampden-Sydney College | Football | III | Football, Lacrosse |
| Logan | Taegan | 2025 | Hampden-Sydney College | Football | III | Football, Baseball |
| McGowan | Patrick | 2025 | Kenyon College | Football | III | Football |
| Murphy | Alexa | 2025 | Old Dominion University | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey |
| Owens | Ethan | 2025 | Anderson University | Lacrosse | II | Lacrosse |
| Patrick | Mason | 2025 | Hampden-Sydney College | Basketball | III | Basketball |
| Puzon | Patrick | 2025 | Lynchburg University | Swimming | III | Swimming |
| Robinson | Isaiah | 2025 | University of Virginia | Football | I | Football, Basketball, Track |
| Rowe | Campbell | 2025 | High Point Univeristy | Lacrosse | I | Lacrosse |
| Sinclair | Ryon | 2025 | Washington & Lee University | Equestrian | NCEA | - |
| Stith | Jordan | 2025 | Christopher Newport University | Football | III | Football |
| Thompson | Brent | 2025 | Randolph College | Basketball | III | Basketball |
| Updike | Vie | 2025 | Randolph-Macon College | Tennis | III | Tennis, Basketball, Soccer |
| Woolman | John | 2025 | Rhodes College | Lacrosse | III | Lacrosse |
| Aisenberg | Sam | 2024 | South Dakota State University | Equestrian | I | None |
| Bailey | Brooke | 2024 | Washington College | Swimming | III | Swimming |
| Chaikin | Alex | 2024 | University of California-San Diego | Basketball | I | Basketball |
| Coles | Trey | 2024 | Eastern Kentucky University | Basketball | I | Basketball |
| Gardiner | Cooper | 2024 | US Naval Academy | Football | I | Football, Winter TF, TF |
| Grant | Trey | 2024 | Virginia State University | Football | I | Football |
| Johnson | Ellie | 2024 | Davidson College | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey |
| Kopsinis | Darcy | 2024 | College of William & Mary | Field Hockey | I | Field Hockey, Lacrosse |
| Mortimer | Marcy | 2024 | Washington and Lee University | Swimming | II | Swimming |
| Mitchell | Ryan | 2024 | University of Pennsylvania | Football | I | Football, Lacrosse |
| Pollard | Julia | 2024 | George Mason University | Womens Lax | I | Lacrosse |
| Pollard | Catherine | 2024 | George Mason University | Womens Lax | I | Tennis, Lacrosse |
| Rainer | Zahir | 2024 | University of Minnesota | Football | I | Football |
| Ramsey | Shepard | 2024 | Sewanee: The University of the South | Field Hockey | III | Field Hockey, Soccer |
| Ridley | Brennan | 2024 | Bowling Green State University | Football | I | Football, Winter TF, Baseball |
| Sims | Nathan | 2024 | University of Rhode Island | Track | I | Soccer, Winter TF, TF |
| Versen | Lilly | 2024 | Washington and Lee University | Track | III | Winter TF, TF |
| Walker | Cam | 2024 | Harvard University | Football | I | Football |
| Watkins | Mia | 2024 | Hood College | Field Hockey | III | Field Hockey |
| Williams | Jay | 2024 | North Carolina A&T State University | Football | I | Football, Lacrosse |
| Williams | Grady | 2024 | College of William & Mary | Golf | I | Tennis, Golf |
| Woodward | James | 2024 | Middlebury College | Football | III | Football |
| Ambrogi Torres | Valentina | 2023 | Randolph-Macon College | Field Hockey | III |
| Badley | Darrick | 2023 | Fairmont State University | Football | II |
| Brooks | John | 2023 | Christopher Newport University | Football | III |
| Brooks | Hunter | 2023 | Davidson College | Football | I |
| Coleman | Leland | 2023 | Columbia University | Basketball | I |
| DiLoreto | TJ | 2023 | Virginia Military Institute | ||
| Dunn | Robbie | 2023 | Virginia Military Institute | Football | I |
| Ferguson | Trai | 2023 | US Naval Academy | Football | I |
| Fisher | Luke | 2023 | Christopher Newport University | Basketball | III |
| Fleet | Kendall | 2023 | Haverford College | Field Hockey | III |
| Fleming | Cam | 2023 | Appalachian State University | Football | I |
| Houston | Matt | 2023 | Christopher Newport University | Football | III |
| Janney | Logan | 2023 | Longwood University | Baseball | I |
| Jenkins | Maisen | 2023 | Bridgewater College | Lacrosse | III |
| Key | Anthony | 2023 | Chowan University | Football | III |
| Miller | Daniel | 2023 | Chatham University | Baseball | III |
| Moore | Carlos | 2023 | Hampton University | Football | I |
| Rainer | Elijah | 2023 | The College of William & Mary | Football | I |
| Schminke | Oliva | 2023 | University of Delaware | Field Hockey | I |
| Shuma | Carter | 2023 | Randolph-Macon College | Baseball | III |
| Stemhagan | JD | 2023 | Manhattan College | Baseball | I |
| Thompson | Mario | 2023 | Old Dominion University | Football | I |
| Winefordner | Neely | 2023 | Randolph-Macon College | Field Hockey | III |
| Last | First | Class of | College | College Sport | Div. |
| Curley | Brian | 2022 | University of Georgia | Baseball | I |
| Erlenbach | Connor | 2022 | Hampden-Sydney College | Lacrosse | III |
| Gorey | Sam | 2022 | University of Mary Washington | Rugby | III |
| Harrison | Josiah | 2022 | Fayetteville Tech CC | Baseball | CC |
| Hart | Jackson | 2022 | Capital University | Lacrosse | III |
| Holloway | Mac | 2022 | Washington and Jefferson College | Lacrosse | III |
| Hoyle | Jack | 2022 | Hampden-Sydney College | Golf | III |
| Kuhla | Garrett | 2022 | James Madison University | Golf | I |
| Murphy-Payne | Sarah | 2022 | Winthrop University | Lacrosse | I |
| Nichols | Lainey | 2022 | University of Richmond | Field Hockey | I |
| Placide | Ally | 2022 | Stevenson University | Soccer | III |
| Pollard | Cole | 2022 | Hampden-Sydney College | Golf | III |
| Pusser | Skyler | 2022 | Christopher Newport University | Track & Field | III |
| Toscano | Jack | 2022 | College of William & Mary | Football | I |
| Whitbeck | Olivia | 2022 | Santa Monica College | Soccer | CC |